A Game of the Year 2013 Poll:

Based on 679 voters (further analysis here):

   FOR THIS GAME, THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE WHO RATED: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920
1. Gone Home (PC)52353018201273555221221111
2. Bioshock Infinite (360, PC, PS3)33322520181515138113665122152
3. Papers, Please (PC)2316171913815799666672313
4. Saints Row IV (360, PC, PS3)3521131712167754633221111
5. Tomb Raider 2013 (360, PC, PS3)142123232195971135332111
6. The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds (3DS)382520151096641241111
7. Pokémon X and Y (3DS)23161522201397105523212
8. The Last Of Us (PS3)5124148344551113233112
9. The Stanley Parable (PC)171513187181171175542333
10. Fire Emblem: Awakening (3DS)2719151110613695452111221
11. Animal Crossing: New Leaf (3DS)1719171161387664312122
12. Grand Theft Auto V (360, PS3)1918109115767154232211
13. Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag (360, PC, PS3, PS4, WiiU, XB1)112017993577422212232
14. Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons (360*, PC, PS3*)71111168810427944411
15. Rogue Legacy (PC)5101010912114758841232141
16. Super Mario 3D World (WiiU)91819994341131111
17. Antichamber (PC)811119113844653121112
18. Gunpoint (PC)41081111637944323231322
19. Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance (360, PS3)15111177522144122111
20. Kentucky Route Zero (PC)1613359435322321
21. Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon (360*, PC, PS3*)4684211911635342211
22. Dota 2 (PC)199485318131123
23. StarCraft II: Heart of the Swarm (PC)129456102436121121
24. Depression Quest (PC)66471146364412312211
25. Shadowrun Returns (Android, PC, iOS)586848663222222243
26. Don't Starve (PC)434774115363455222213
27. Monaco: What's Yours is Mine (360*, PC)6575686254531321231
28. Ni No Kuni (PS3)24888771333312121
29. Candy Box (PC)22642542697235464322
30. Guacamelee! (PC, PS3*, Vita*)3105757625424211323
31. Risk of Rain (PC)7495422732114212121
32. Shin Megami Tensei IV (3DS)65543374453212211
33. Hate Plus (PC)986345223221111
34. Cookie Clicker (PC)141543679326344111
35. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Dual Destinies (3DS*)256575110233111
36. Path of Exile (PC)38442454341131221
37. Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn (PC, PS3)5266625323311111
38. Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon (3DS)24335746332333521
39. DmC: Devil May Cry (360, PC, PS3)11625645343412311111
40. Batman: Arkham Origins (360, PC, PS3)42446634331232211
41. Proteus (PC, PS3, Vita)44322633252132232
42. Long Live the Queen (PC)12353442342433121
43. A Dark Room (iOS, PC)1253272332242212122
44. Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate (3DS, WiiU)545424521312
45. Divekick (PC, PS3*, PS4*, Vita*)12313163643413313111
46. 868-HACK (iOS, PC)105532132121
47. Dragon's Crown (PS3*, Vita*)13563423141112112
48. The Swapper (PC)2336134332212222
49. Call of Juarez: Gunslinger (360*, PC, PS3*)3346531522214
50. Etrian Odyssey IV: Legends of the Titan (3DS)714126312113311
51. Bit.Trip Presents Runner 2: Future Legend of Rhythm Alien (360*, iOS, PC, PS3*, Vita, WiiU*)135142415133311111
52. Payday 2 (PC)226131133344221111
53. Pikmin 3 (WiiU)23363132522122
54. Salty Bet (PC)221222231274544122
55. The Wonderful 101 (WiiU)54145312121221
56. Ridiculous Fishing (Android, iOS)213152343314124212
57. SUPERHOT (PC)23213315133342121
58. Bubsy 3d: Bubsy Visits the James Turrell Retrospective (PC)2111636412121221111
59. Battlefield 4 (360, PC, PS3, PS4, XB1)35312315113131111
60. State of Decay (360*, PC)22334325221222
61. Ducktales Remastered (360, PC, PS3, WiiU)2512534261211
62. Rayman Legends (360, PC, PS3, Vita, WiiU)224321621411311
63. Warframe (PC, PS4*)11542331112313141
64. Lego Marvel Super Heroes (360, 3DS, DS, PC, PS3, PS4, WiiU, XB1, Vita)34562331141211
65. Surgeon Simulator 2013 (PC)12143135321313111
66. Remember Me (360, PC, PS3)141232113322121113
67. Tearaway (Vita)3431231213111
68. Dead Space 3 (360, PC, PS3)1133631321131111
69. Injustice: Gods Among Us (360, PC, PS3, PS4, Vita, Wii U)112222433232211
70. Penny Arcade's On The Rain-Slick Precipice of Darkness 4 (PC, 360*)21213652242111
71. Candy Box 2 (PC)11221353131151
72. Euro Truck Simulator 2 (PC)2113325111113211
73. Tales of Xillia (PS3)12312231122212
74. Europa Universalis IV (PC)23511311221
75. Geoguesser (PC)122122422121111
76. The Yawhg (PC)141413212211
77. Marvel Heroes (PC)3114212441111
78. HORSEMASTER The Game of Horse Mastery (PC)22222131231
79. Rune Factory 4 (3DS)24211223131111
80. Anodyne (Android, PC)3221122123122
81. Kindness Coins (PC)21413121321
82. Device 6 (iOS)123223131111
83. Metro: Last Light (360, PC, PS3)213122122112131
84. Typing of the Dead: Overkill (PC)2213241241123
85. Resogun (PS4*)2333113311111
86. Fjords (PC)243221211
87. All I Want is for All of my Friends to Become Insanely Powerful (PC)21321251211
88. Shadow Warrior (PC)222122213211
89. New Super Luigi U (WiiU)2411222211231
90. Ys: Memories of Celceta (Vita)3312113111
91. Rymdkapsel (Android, iOS, Vita*)1114232212311
92. Beyond: Two Souls (PS3)14122131211111
93. Mario & Luigi: Dream Team (3DS)2123411111121
94. Eldritch (PC)114213221212
95. No-one has to die. (PC)14212222112
96. Ultra Business Tycoon III (PC)42222121
97. Problem Attic (PC)423111121
98. Reus (PC)11123112131111
99. Game Dev Tycoon (PC)12114121212
100. Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers (3DS)12113111211111
101. Neverwinter (PC)221422111
102. Rocksmith 2014 (360, PC, PS3)4312111
103. Jelly No Puzzle (PC)112232111111
104. BattleBlock Theater (360*)12133111111
105. Save the Date (PC)111431321
106. Soul Sacrifice (Vita)11221322111
107. Samurai Gunn (PC)32212211
108. SimCity (PC)14311111111
109. 10 Seconds In Hell (PC)3311311
110. Even Cowgirls Bleed (PC)13211112222111
111. Poker Night 2 (360*, iOS, PC, PS3*)11124111221122
112. ARMA 3 (PC)1212221121
113. Shelter (PC)1433111
114. Magic the Gathering Duels of the Planeswalkers 2014 (360*, Android, iOS, PC, PS3*)112311111122111
115. SABBAT (PC)21311221
116. Marvel Puzzle Quest: Dark Reign (Android, iOS, PC)14113121
117. Room of 1000 Snakes (PC)12211112311
118. Player 2 (PC)131111121
119. Receiver (PC)121111221221
120. Year Walk (iOS)2121211112
121. Defiance (360, PC, PS3)131311111212
122. The Cave (360*, iOS, Ouya, PC, PS3*, WiiU*)1112122111121
123. Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs (PC)1111111211112
124. Killer Instinct (XB1)211322111
125. Etrian Odyssey Untold: The Millennium Girl (3DS)13121311
126. Sacrilege (PC)1111111121111
127. Killzone: Shadow Fall (PS4)11312111221
128. Plants vs Zombies 2: It's About Time (Android, iOS)1151221221
129. My Father’s Long, Long legs (PC)321311
130. Knights of Pen and Paper (iOS, Android, PC)111131131113
131. Lego City Undercover (WiiU)11111531
132. Valdis Story: The Abyssal City (PC)211222111
133. Crypt Worlds: Your Darkest Desires, Come True (PC)11111211111
134. Steamworld Dig (3DS, PC)11211213121
135. Dead Rising 3 (XB1)111214112
136. Giana Sisters: Twisted Dreams - Rise of the Owlverlord (360*, PC, PS3*)311211111
137. Queers in Love at the End of the World (PC)1111111121
138. Forza Motorsport 5 (XB1)13211111
139. Punch Quest (Android, iOS)1111111111111
140. Anne Hathaway Erotic Mouthscape (PC)11222111
141. Experiment 12 (PC)122112111
142. Volgarr the Viking (PC)2111121111
143. Call of Duty: Ghosts (360, PC, PS3, PS4, WiiU, XB1)1112122111
144. Sword of the Stars: The Pit (PC)11112111111
145. Evoland (PC)1112211111
146. Heroes of Sokoban 1-3 (PC)2121111
147. Electronic Super Joy (PC)112111111111
148. The Entertainment (PC)32111
149. Hammerwatch (PC)11322111
150. You Will Select a Decision, No. 2: Cow Farming Activities on the Former West (PC)2221112
151. SolForge (iOS, PC)211111111
152. Deadpool (360, PC, PS3)322211111
153. Anhedonia (PC)11113211
154. Naya's Quest (PC)1131211
155. Attack of the Friday Monsters! A Tokyo Tale (3DS*)11122121
156. Skulls of the Shogun (360*, iOS, PC, WP)1112111221
157. MirrorMoon EP (PC)212122
158. Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Blacklist (360, PC, PS3, WiiU)12111212
159. Actual Sunlight (PC)1311211
160. AEGIS WING (Anna Anthropy) (PC)12312
161. Race the Sun (PC)11111221
162. Gun Godz (PC)11111121111
163. Strike Suit Zero (PC)1111111122
164. Mechwarrior Online (PC)131211
165. Total War: Rome II (PC)1122111
166. Dynasty Warriors 8 (360, PS3, PS4, Vita)112212
167. Towerfall (Ouya)111211
168. Bleed (360*, PC)1111111
169. Skylanders: Swap Force (360, 3DS, PS3, PS4, Wii, WiiU)311111
170. NES Remix (WiiU*)1221113
171. Destroy Your Home (PC)1211111
172. Lake of Roaches (PC)1211111
173. Westerado (PC)11211121
174. Ittle Dew (Android, iOS, PC)211211111
175. Your Swimsuit Jumped Over Its Own Weathercock, You Liar! (PC)211111
176. How to Speak Atlantean (PC)1112111
177. Dominique Pamplemousse in “It's All Over Once The Fat Lady Sings!” (iOS, PC)312
178. Disney Infinity (360, 3DS, iOS, PS3, Wii, WiiU)1111111
179. FIFA 14 (Android, 360, 3DS, iOS, PC, PS2, PS3, PS4, PSP, Vita, Wii, XB1)11211111
180. Picross e / Picross e2 (3DS*)11111112
181. Castlevania: Lords of Shadow – Mirror of Fate (360*, 3DS, PS3*)121211
182. Outlast (PC)111111111
183. Sang-Froid: Tales of Werewolves (PC)1111111
184. Project X Zone (3DS)1111211111
185. Counterfeit Monkey (PC)1112
186. Namco High (PC)111111
187. Anarchy Reigns (360, PS3)211122
188. D&D Lords of Waterdeep (iOS)11211
189. Pandora’s Tower (Wii)31131
190. Gran Turismo 6 (PS3)11111
191. Super House of Dead Ninjas (PC)1311111
192. Rise of the Triad 2013 (PC)12211
193. Sly Cooper: Thieves in Time (PS3, Vita)1121121
194. Zeno Clash II (360*, PC, PS3*)1112111
195. The Room Two (iOS)11111
196. Contrast (360*, PC, PS3*, PS4*)1111111
197. Flower Town / Mii Force / Monster Manor / Warrior’s Way (3DS*)11111
198. Art Game (PC)112121
199. The Banner Saga: Factions (PC)12111
200. Positive Space (PC)11111
201. Divinity: Dragon Commander (PC)111111
202. BADLAND (Android, Blackberry,iOS)1111221
203. NBA 2K14 (Android, 360, iOS, PC, PS3, PS4, XB1)1111111
204. 140 (PC)212
205. The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing (PC, 360)111111
206. Senran Kagura Burst (3DS*)111111
207. The Bureau: XCOM Declassified (360, PC, PS3)111111
208. Mighty Switch Force 2 (3DS*, WiiU*)111211
209. Triad (PC)11111
210. 000000052573743 (PC)2111
211. Redshirt (PC)11211
212. Temple Run 2 (Android, iOS, WP8)112111
213. Blues for Mittavinda (PC)1111
214. Peggle 2 (XB1)1212
215. Madden NFL 25 (360, iOS, PS3, PS4, XB1)111111
216. Legend of Dungeon (PC)111111121
217. Space Hulk (iOS, PC)11111
218. Kingdom Rush: Frontiers (Android, iOS, PC)112122
219. Killzone: Mercenary (Vita)1121
220. EVE: DUST 514 (PS3*)1111
221. Breaking Bread (PC)1111
222. Killer Is Dead (360, PS3)21111
223. Disgaea Dimension 2 (PS3)311
224. EGGNOGG (PC)2111
225. Ryse: Son of Rome (XB1)1111111
226. Hexcells (PC)1111
227. Solstice Arena (Android, iOS, PC)1111
228. Dang I'm Huge (PC)1211
229. Knock-knock (PC)11112
230. Ending (Aaron Steed) (iOS, PC)11112
231. Cry of Fear (PC)1211
232. Monster Loves You! (Android, iOS, PC)111111
233. Yume Nikki 3D (PC)1111
234. Need for Speed: Rivals (360, PC, PS3, PS4, XB1)1111111
235. Sanctum 2 (PC)11111
236. Ride to Hell: Retribution (360, PC, PS3)12
237. The Walking Dead: Survival Instict (360, PC, PS3, WiiU)111
238. MURI (PC)12
239. Driftmoon (PC)12
240. Dominions 4: Thrones of Ascension (PC)111
241. Company of Heroes 2 (PC)111111
242. Skyward Collapse (PC)11111
243. Gods Will Be Watching (PC)2111
244. Megabyte Punch (PC)1111
245. Super Puzzle Platformer Deluxe (PC)112
246. Warhammer Quest (iOS)1111
247. Halo: Spartan Assault (360, PC, WP8, XB1)121
248. Bionic Dues (PC)111
249. UN EP (PC)112
250. Grid 2 (360, PC, PS3)111
251. Strike Suit Infinity (PC)11111
252. Mars: War Logs (360*, PC, PS3*)111
253. Angry Video Game Nerd Adventures (PC)1111
254. Asphalt 8: Airborne (Android, iOS, PC, WP8)111
255. Ratchet and Clank: Into the Nexus (PS3)1111
256. Game & Wario (WiiU)1111
257. Negative Space (PC)1111
258. Knack (PS4)311
259. God of War: Ascension (PS3)1112
260. Puppeteer (PS3)111
261. Deus Ex: The Fall (iOS)1111
262. Capsule (PC)2
263. One Piece: Pirate Warriors 2 (PS3)21
264. NHL 14 (360, PS3)12
265. Sex with men (PC)111
266. The Great Work (PC)121
267. WWE 2K14 (360, PS3)21
268. Mega Man Unlimited (PC)11
269. Let’s Play: Ancient Greek Geometry (PC)11
270. Cataclysm: Dark Days Ahead (PC)11
271. Ollam House (PC)1111
272. Soundodger+ (PC)1111
273. Super Stickman Golf 2 (Android, iOS)111
274. Cratopia (PC)11
275. Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm 3 (360, PC, PS3)11
276. Digimon World Re:Digitize Decode (3DS)11
277. Eador: Masters of the Broken World (PC)11
278. Standstill Girl (PC)11
279. Tekken Revolution (PS3*)111
280. Gears of War: Judgment (360)1112
281. Rain (PS3*)11
282. Cities in Motion 2 (PC)111
283. Journaličre (PC)2
284. Simian.interface (PC)11111
285. Wargame: AirLand Battle (PC)11
286. 4-Lung Boy (PC)12
287. Papa Sangre II (iOS)11
288. Cloudberry Kingdom (360*, PC, PS3*, Wii U*, Vita*)111
289. Castle of Illusion Starring Mickey Mouse (360*, iOS, PC, PS3*)111
290. Trackmania 2 Valley (PC)1112
291. Lakeview Cabin (PC)11111
292. Batman: Arkham Origins - Blackgate (3DS, Vita)111
293. Just Dance 2014 (360, PS3, PS4, Wii, WiiU, XB1)111
294. Impostor Syndrome (PC)11
295. Inquisitor (PC)11
296. Harmoknight (3DS*)1211
297. Mario and Donkey Kong: Minis on the Move (3DS*)11
298. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows (360*, PC, PS3*)11
299. Dead Island: Riptide (360, PC, PS3)111
300. Omerta: City of Gangsters (360, PC)11
301. Expeditions: Conquistador (PC)111
302. Aliens: Colonial Marines (360, PC, PS3)11
303. Slender: The Arrival (PC)111
304. Gingiva (PC)11
305. Stardrive (PC)11
306. Final Fantasy XI: Seekers of Adoulin (360, PC)11
307. Dream Fishing (PC)11
308. Composition 37 (PC)11
309. InFlux (PC)111
310. Mashkin Sees it Through (PC)11
311. Wii Party U (WiiU)121
312. Césure (PC)111
313. Reveal (PC)11
314. Sacred Citadel (360*, PC, PS3*)11
315. Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Gates to Infinity (3DS)111
316. Dungeonland (PC)11
317. Pan Man (PC)11
318. Manos: The Hands of Fate (Android, iOS, PC)11
319. Four Scepters (PC)21
320. Viscera Cleanup Detail (PC)11
321. ALPHABET (PC)21
322. Cut the Rope 2 (iOS)11
323. Lime Rick (PC)2
324. X Rebirth (PC)11
325. Unepic (PC, WiiU)11
326. I Hate the Dark (PC)1
327. Wizardry Online (PC)1
328. Heroine's Quest: The Herald of Ragnarok (PC)1
329. A Kiss (PC)2
330. FIFA Manager 14 (PC)1
331. Coloratura (PC)1
332. I Am Level (iOS, PC)11
333. Castle of the Red Prince (PC)1
334. Unbreakable (PC)1
335. Questlord (Android, iOS)11
336. Football Manager 2014 (Android, iOS, PC)11
337. Wii Sports Club (WiiU*)11
338. Galah Galah (PC)11
339. Princess Chardonnay in Bomb Kingdom (PC)1
340. One Finger Death Punch (360*, PC)11
341. Beatbuddy: Tale of the Guardians (PC)1
342. The Night of the Rabbit (PC)1
343. The Day the Laughter Stopped (PC)1
344. Toki Tori 2 (PC, WiiU)11
345. MLB 13: The Show (PS3, Vita)1
346. Zoo Tycoon 2013 (360, XB1)1
347. Fuck that Guy (PC)11
348. Sonic Lost World (WiiU)11
349. Infinity Blade III (iOS)1111
350. Retrovirus (PC)1
351. It Dies in the Night (PC)11
352. Sepes Cumshot (PC)11
353. JASON AND THE ARGONAUTS (PC)1
354. God Mode (PC)11
355. Ring Runner: Flight of the Sages (PC)1
356. Ex Nihilo (PC)1
357. TIMEframe (PC)1
358. Life & Minimalism (PC)1
359. Tennis Elbow 2013 (PC)1
360. Final Fantasy All the Bravest (Android, iOS)1
361. Stop Me If You’ve Heard This One Before (PC)11
362. How to Survive (PC)11
363. Richard and Alice (PC)11
364. Savant Ascent (PC)11
365. Teslagrad (PC)1
366. Leviathan Warships (Android, iOS, PC)1
367. Music of the Spheres (PC)1
368. Dillon's Rolling Western: The Last Ranger (3DS*)21
369. Magrunner: Dark Pulse (PC, 360*, PS3*)11
370. Impire (PC)11
371. NCAA Football 14 (360, PS3)1
372. Anomaly 2 (Android, iOS, PC)2
373. Foiled (PC)1
374. Icefishing V (PC)1
375. Sonic Dash (Android, iOS)1
376. Age of Wushu (PC)1
377. Pro Evolution Soccer 2014 (360, 3DS, PC, PS2, PS3, PSP, Vita)1
378. The Novelist (PC)1
379. Injustice: Gods Among Us (Android, iOS)1
380. Pokémon Rumble U (WiiU*)11
381. Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Winter Games Sochi 2014 (WiiU)1
382. Lost Planet 3 (360, PC, PS3)1
383. Tetrobot and Co. (PC)1
384. Melodisle (PC)1
385. Dragon Fantasy Book II (PS3*, Vita*)1
386. Symbol (PC)1
387. Tetris Blitz (Android, iOS)1
388. EMMA (PC)1
389. Pause Ahead (PC)1
390. Ultima Forever: Quest for the Avatar (iOS)1
391. Deep Dungeons of Doom (Android, iOS, Ouya)1
392. Phantom Breaker: Battle Grounds (360*)1
393. Mandala (PC)1
394. The Playroom (PS4)11
395. Jacob Jones and the Bigfoot Mystery (Vita*, iOS)1
396. Sorcery Saga: The Curse of the Great Curry God (Vita)11
397. The Ruins of Machi Itcza (PC)1
398. Crysis 3 (360, PC, PS3)12
399. Tiger Woods PGA Tour 14 (360, PS3)1
400. Charlie Murder (360*)1
401. Valhalla Knights 3 (Vita)1
402. Composition 62 (PC)1
403. Ultionus: A Tale of Petty Revenge (PC)1